Every Pick. Every Result. Fully Documented.

Welcome to the official Pappy’s PlayBook 2026 MLB documented picks page.

This is where every official MLB wager is tracked throughout the season—from Opening Day through the World Series. Each play is recorded with the posted odds, wager type, unit size, and final result, giving you a clear and honest look at our performance.

No selective screenshots. No disappearing losses. No inflated winning percentages.

Just documented picks, transparent results, and a disciplined approach built for the long baseball season.

What Counts as an Official Pick?

A selection counts toward the documented record only when it is released as an official Pappy’s PlayBook play before the scheduled start of the game.

Every documented selection includes:

  • The teams and matchup
  • The exact wager being played
  • The available odds at the time of release
  • The recommended unit size
  • The final result
  • The number of units won or lost

Opinions, leans, game notes, and possible plays are not added to the official record unless they are clearly released as wagers.

That distinction matters. A betting record should reflect the plays customers were actually given—not every passing opinion that happened to be correct.

How Results Are Graded

Pappy’s PlayBook uses consistent grading standards throughout the 2026 MLB season.

Odds at release: Results are calculated using the line posted with the original selection. Bettors may receive a slightly different number depending on their sportsbook and the time the wager is placed.

Unit-based tracking: Performance is measured in units rather than dollars. This allows bettors with different bankroll sizes to evaluate the record on the same scale.

Pushes: A push is recorded separately and does not count as a win or loss.

Postponements and no-action wagers: Any wager cancelled under standard sportsbook rules is removed from the win-loss calculation and produces no unit gain or loss.

No retroactive changes: Picks are not added, removed, or altered after a game begins to improve the published record.

Types of MLB Picks We Track

The documented record may include several MLB betting markets:

Moneylines — Selecting the team expected to win the game.

Game totals — Wagering on whether the combined score will finish over or under the posted number.

Pitcher Strikeouts — Isolating the starting-pitcher

Team totals — Betting on the number of runs scored by one team.

Not every market will produce an official play every day. The wager type depends on where the strongest combination of matchup advantage and market value appears.

Quality Picks. No Noise.

Pappy’s PlayBook is not built around forcing a full card of action. Some days may produce several opportunities. Other days may produce one selection—or none at all.

Passing on a weak number is part of the process.

Our focus is straightforward: study the full MLB card, identify the best available betting opportunities, release selections at playable prices, and document the results honestly.

There are no guaranteed winners in sports betting. What we can provide is a clear process, disciplined selection standards, and an accountable record that bettors can review for themselves.

2026 Documented Record -> 34-18 (65%) +$11,090
7/11/2026Toronto Blue Jays -105San Diego Padres 8-7($1,050)
7/9/2026Bryce Miller OVER 5.5 K’s5 K’s($1,480)
7/8/2026Detroit Tigers OVER 4.5 Runs6 Runs$1,000
7/7/2026LA Dodgers OVER 5.5 Runs3 Runs($1,100)
7/6/2026Christopher Sanchez OVER 6.5 K’s1 K($550)
7/5/2026Tampa Bay Rays OVER 4.5 Runs0 Runs($550)
7/4/2026Pittsburgh Pirates OVER 5.5 Runs7 Runs$1,000
7/3/2026LA Dodgers OVER 4.5 Runs4 Runs($550)
7/2/2026Nathan Eovaldi OVER 6.5 K’s9 K’s$500
7/1/2026OVER 9Milwaukee Brewers 4-2($550)
6/30/2026Philadelphia Phillies OVER 4.5 Runs 8 Runs$500
6/29/2026Ranger Saurez OVER 5.5 K’s8 K’s$500
6/28/2026Tampa Bay Rays OVER 4.5 Runs5 Runs$500
6/27/2026OVER 9.5Colorado Rockies 8-5$500
6/27/2026Detroit Tigers -136Houston Astros 8-6($680)
6/26/2026Tampa Bay Rays OVER 4.5 Runs6 Runs$500
6/25/2026Cam Schittler OVER 6.5 K’s9 K’s$500
6/24/2026Arizona Diamondbacks OVER 4.5 Runs9 Runs$1,000
6/23/2026Shane Baz OVER 5.5 K’s5 K’s($550)
6/21/2026Philadelphia Phillies OVER 4.5 Runs 6 Runs$500
6/20/2026Paul Skenes OVER 6.5 K’s8 K’s$1,000
6/19/2026Arizona Diamondbacks OVER 4.5 Runs9 Runs$500
6/18/2026Joe Ryan OVER 6.5 K’s7 K’s$1,000
6/17/2026Boston Red Sox OVER 4.5 Runs0 Runs($1,100)
6/16/2026Cincinnati Reds OVER 4.5 Runs5 Runs$500
6/15/2026St Louis Cardinals OVER 4.5 Runs3 Runs($550)
6/15/2026OVER 9Washington Nationals 7-3$500
6/12/2026Milwaukee Brewers OVER 4.5 Runs6 Runs$1,000
6/10/2026Chicago Cubs OVER 6.5 Runs2 Runs($550)
6/9/2026Taj Bradley OVER 5.5 K’s3 K’s($550)
6/8/2026Houston Astros OVER 4.5 Runs5 Runs$500
6/7/2026Cade Cavalli OVER 4.5 K’s2 K’s($550)
6/6/2026LA Dodgers OVER 5.5 Runs9 Runs$500
6/5/2026Bryan Woo OVER 5.5 K’s7 K’s$500
6/4/2026Minnesota Twins OVER 4.5 Runs6 Runs$500
6/3/2026Chase Burns OVER 6.5 K’s 9 K’s$500
6/2/2026Joey Cantillo UNDER 4.5 K’s4 K’s$500
6/1/2026Joe Ryan OVER 5.5 K’s9K’s$500
5/31/2026OVER 8Baltimore Orioles 9-5$500
5/30/2026UNDER 9Atlanta Braves 5-2$1,000
5/29/2026UNDER 10.5Colorado Rockies 8-6($550)
5/28/2026UNDER 8.5Toronto Blue Jays 2-1$1,000
5/27/2026OVER 8Boston Red Sox 8-0$0
5/26/2026OVER 7.5Cincinnati Reds 7-2$1,000
5/25/2026OVER 8Washington Nationals 10-2$1,000
5/24/2026UNDER 9San Francisco Giants 8-5($550)
5/23/2026OVER 9San Francisco Giants 10-3$1,000
5/22/2026OVER 7.5San Diego Padres 7-3$500
5/21/2026Toronto Blue Jays +120Toronto Blue 2-0$1,200
5/20/2026Washington Nationals +100Washington Nationals 8-4$1,000
5/19/2026Colorado Rockies -110Texas Rangers 10-0($1,100)
5/18/2026Kansas City Royals -110Boston Red Sox 3-0($550)
5/17/2026OVER 8Texas Rangers 8-0$0
5/16/2026OVER 7.5Miami Marlins 10-5$1,000